The all-in-one Permute alternative for Mac
Both are offline Mac converters. Permute is the cheaper one and adds timeline video editing. Picmal adds compression for images, video, audio, and PDFs, plus PDF tools and folder monitoring.
Pay once, 14-day refund. Requires macOS 15 or later.
TL;DR Picmal vs Permute
Picmal ($29) and Permute (~$14.99, also on Setapp) are both offline Mac converters, with Permute the cheaper of the two. Picmal compresses images, video, audio, and PDFs, with PDF tools, folder monitoring, and Finder right-click. Permute adds timeline editing (trim, crop, merge) and audio normalization.
- Pick Picmal if
- You convert and compress media on your Mac and want folder monitoring, PDF tools, and a Finder right-click, and you don't need to trim or merge videos.
- Pick Permute if
- You need to trim, crop, or merge videos, normalize audio, batch edit metadata, schedule conversions, or pull text out of images with OCR. Or you already pay for Setapp.
What is Permute 3?
Permute 3 is the Mac media converter from Charlie Monroe Software for macOS 11 to 15 and Intel Macs. Permute 4 is the newer version. It needs macOS 26 and an Apple Silicon Mac. Both convert video, audio and images offline, so your files stay on the machine.
I make Picmal, so weigh what I say. Permute does something Picmal does not: it trims, crops and stitches video. The developer lists the current versions and the upgrade terms on the Permute page. If you want one Mac app for conversion, compression and PDFs, the table below shows where Picmal fits, and Permute vs Picmal goes through the two side by side.
Picmal vs Permute at a glance
| Feature | Picmal | Permute |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $29 one-time | $14.99 one-time |
| Setapp | No | Yes, included in the subscription |
| Privacy | 100% offline | 100% offline |
| Interface | One window, no hunting through menus | Groups + presets |
| Image formats | 20+ | 15+ |
| Compression | Images, video, audio & PDF, never bigger than the original | Target file size when converting |
| PDF tools | Compress, combine, images to PDF | PDF pages to images |
| Video editing | No | Trim, crop, stitch |
| Metadata | Strip location data before sharing | Batch metadata editor |
| Shortcuts | Yes | Yes |
| Automatic conversion | Watches a folder, converts what lands in it | Drop zones, drop files onto a preset |
| Finder right-click | Yes, convert without opening the app | No |
| macOS | 15+ | 26+, Apple Silicon only (Permute 4) |
From the people
who use it
Pay once and you're all set
One price, every tool, yours to keep.
How many Macs?
Half price until 30 November.
2 Macs is $10 more2 Macs is $5 more
14-day refund. Requires macOS 15 or later.
What you get
-
Convert, compress and edit images, video, audio and PDFs
-
Everything runs on your Mac, nothing gets uploaded
-
Use it on 1 Mac
-
Command line tool, Raycast extension and watched folders
-
Free updates forever, no subscription
More than 10 Macs? Email me.
Upgrades, new Macs and discounts are in the FAQ.
Frequently asked questions
Can't find what you're looking for? Email support@picmal.app
Is Picmal a good Permute alternative?
If you don't need to trim, crop, or merge video, then yes. Picmal converts, compresses, and handles images, video, audio, and PDFs in one window. Permute adds a video editing layer. Picmal skips it.
Does Picmal work offline like Permute?
Yes. Everything runs locally on your Mac. Nothing gets uploaded anywhere.
Can Picmal convert and compress video and audio?
Yes. Picmal converts video (MP4, MOV, MKV, and more) and audio (MP3, WAV, FLAC, and more). It compresses all of them, images, video, audio, and PDFs, and the output is never larger than the input. No timeline editing though. No trimming, cropping, or merging.
Is Picmal actually cheaper than Permute?
No, Permute is cheaper. As of October it's $14.99 for up to three activations, and it's on Setapp if you pay for that. Picmal is $29 for one Mac and $39 for two. What you get for the difference is PDF compression and combining, a watched folder that converts whatever lands in it, and a Finder right-click. Picmal also runs on macOS 15, where Permute 4 needs macOS 26 and an Apple Silicon Mac.
Is Permute 3 still sold?
Yes, as of October. The developer sells Permute 3 at $14.99 for macOS 11 to 15 and for Intel Macs. Permute 4 needs macOS 26 and an Apple Silicon Mac.
What is the difference between Permute 3 and Permute 4?
Permute 4 is the newer version. It needs macOS 26 and an Apple Silicon Mac, and it has its own license. Permute 3 covers macOS 11 to 15 and Intel Macs. As of October the developer gives Permute 3 buyers a free upgrade when they move to macOS 26.
Is the Permute app a subscription?
No. Permute 3 and Permute 4 are one-time purchases at $14.99 as of October. The Permute Mac app is also in Setapp, which is a monthly subscription.
What if Picmal doesn't work for me?
Full refund within 14 days, no questions asked. Just email support@picmal.app.
How does the license work?
You pay once and keep it. No renewals, no subscriptions. Your license activates on the number of Macs you bought it for, and you can move it to another Mac whenever you want. Prices are in USD, tax is added at checkout, and you pay through Stripe.
I bought Picmal and now I need more Macs. Can I upgrade?
Yes, and you only pay the difference. Going from 1 Mac to 2 is $10, 2 to 5 is $50, 5 to 10 is $60, and every other jump works the same way. Enter your license key here and the same key covers more Macs. The offer never expires, so starting small is never the wrong call.
What happens if I get a new Mac?
Open Picmal on your old Mac, go to Picmal → Register license to deactivate, then activate on the new one. Takes about ten seconds.
Do you offer student or country discounts?
Yes. I want Picmal to be affordable wherever you are. Students and educators get 40% off: verify your school email on the education page and the code lands in your inbox. If the price is steep for your country, checkout already adjusts it for you. If it still doesn't work, email support@picmal.app and tell me where you are, and I'll send a code.

